« Sustainable Countertop Material | Main | Bona fide and nationwide! NAHB is going green »
November 22, 2007
Now for thoughts on... flooring material?
When I blogged about countertop material, I got such a great list of resources and things to consider that I decided to ask you readers again, on a different topic - floors.
What do you think of sustainable flooring materials? What are the options, the considerations and the costs?
We're going to be adding about 800 square feet of office space above the garage in our new home. I don't want to carpet it, for a variety of reasons.
I'm looking for natural, reclaimed, recycled or easily renewable flooring options - that DON'T cost an arm and a leg.
Talk to me. What are your thoughts? Bamboo is an option (that has downfalls), reclaimed barn wood (I thought this would be inexpensive but OUCH it's not), I don't love marmoleum and other synthetics...
I'm secretly hoping Melissa will see this and write me another essay on the environmental friendliness of flooring materials. LOL.
Posted by Stacy Hunt at November 22, 2007 10:53 AM
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://blogs.scrippsnetworks.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/851
Comments
I installed bamboo throughout my home and am not impressed with the quality. It doesn't seem so hard to me, as it has many scrapes and dents after 6 months and in some places is seems to be getting hairline fractures. We tried to research it and get the right kind, but we found that everyone was trying to sell us the same brand at different prices. True linoleum is enviromentally friendly, tough, and can look very nice. Although it seems hard to find. I was recently looking at rubber which was really nice looking, but kind of plain--nothing a wool area rug can't fix. Great for clean ups to!!!
Posted by: Jess at November 28, 2007 7:06 AM
cork or recycled cork flooring materials may be a good fit for your criterias.
Posted by: HanH Tran at November 28, 2007 7:51 AM
What are the downsides to bamboo? Anybody have long-term residential experience with stained concrete?
*** It's my understanding that bamboo has to be of a certain age to be truly durable, and most bamboo flooring sold is young and "impressionable" (ha, ha). Meaning, it's not tough enough and has issues like what another poster mentioned... it gets dented and beaten up easily.
I'd love to do stained concrete, but not above my garage. ;) - Stacy
Posted by: mdestrin at November 28, 2007 8:04 AM
I suggest that you consider using cork for your new office space. It's renewable, excellent color choices, warm to the touch, competitively priced, and installs quickly. I plan to use the floating floor style in my new kitchen.
Jim
Posted by: Jim Rygh at November 28, 2007 10:46 AM
What about cork flooring. It's a renewable source as well as an insulator and soundproofing material.
Posted by: Mike J. at November 28, 2007 11:28 AM
The best kitchen floor I ever had was industrial grade linoleum in a dark slightly spattered pattern. Indestructible sheen, tight seams. But I HADDA have heart pine.
*** Yeah, those HADDA HAVEITs will getcha every time. Probably what will keep me from linoleum, myself. ;) - Stacy
Posted by: Rose at November 28, 2007 1:36 PM
True recycled wood flooring does seem expensive at first glance, but if you look around you can find some good deals. I work for Pioneer Millworks, one of the larger reclaimed wood companies in the US. We have a plethora of flooring options on our website, www.pioneermillworks.com. There you�ll also find our Bargain Basement, where we list over-runs or extra inventory, with considerable savings. There�s nothing wrong with the flooring, we simply discount it to free up shop space! No matter the cost, or where you�re buying, there's several questions to ask:
1. Is the wood kiln-dried? Any good flooring manufacturer will kiln-dry their wood for stability. While reclaimed wood is inherently more dry than green material, it still needs to be dried for consistency, and to prevent any possible insect infestation.
2. Is the wood 100% reclaimed? There's reclaimed / recycled wood, and then there's "old-growth" woods. The latter is not reclaimed or recycled at all - its cut from newly harvested trees which happen to be quite old. True reclaimed wood has been salvaged from a structure or previous use, and the company should be able to tell you where the wood came from. You get a great floor, and a great conversation piece!
3. Is the company reputable? Plenty of companies make reclaimed wood flooring, but the differences in quality amongst them are tremendous. Look for a firm thats been around for a long time, and has a proven track record of consistent materials and good availability. Make sure that what you see and order is what you�re going to get � this can be accomplished through written specifications, samples, and photographs.
The cost of recycled wood can range from $3 to $30 per square foot, but generally speaking, softer woods like White Pine or Hemlock will be less expensive than White Oak, for instance. At Pioneer Millworks, we offer a broad range of species, styles, grades, and widths to accommodate virtually any project, including this one over the garage. Our Sierra�s Choice Yellow Pine would fit the bill, and a low VOC finish such as a botanical Tung Oil would top off the floor perfectly and stick with the environmental goals of the project.
Hope this helps and gives you some good information to work from � drop me a note anytime you want to talk reclaimed wood. Thanks!
AWESOME comments. Thanks for so much to think about! - Stacy
Posted by: Jered Slusser at November 28, 2007 2:42 PM
What about cork? I was just looking it up (on www.lumberliquidators.com) for my daughter's home. It sounds like a good alternative and perfect for the space you are talking about. There are some reviews to read in there.
Posted by: Kay at November 28, 2007 4:20 PM
Has anyone lived with cork for a while? Does it hold up well?
Posted by: Janet at November 29, 2007 12:21 PM
Hey Stacy,
Wow, people are excited about cork! I have no experience with it, except for the floor at Artemis is Pittsburgh. Go talk to Janice or Linda about it when you're back in the Burgh. They've got a huge range of this stuff and love to talk about it. Their website is http://www.artemisenvironmental.com/
I think cork is probably a good choice for an office floor. I do like Marmoleum (natural linoleum) as well. I will have some going into my house after I finish the bathroom renovation.
Jered's comments about reclaimed wood are interesting. Is there a Construction Junction or Habitat ReStore sort of place nearby? They might also be a source for pre-used hardwood flooring. Of course, that requires some efforts that other options don't.
-Eric
Posted by: Eric Helton at December 3, 2007 12:37 AM
